@English Catholic I did not say you are obliged to believe private revelations but there's a big difference between not believing and being quiet about it vs speaking out publicly against and passing severe judgment. Second, regarding obedience, CDF is taken over by a man who is not even Catholic and issues ungodly statements. As per bishops, unfortunately great number of them have publicly apostatized. Our obedience is to Our Lord Jesus Christ and to perennial teachings of His Church and not to someone who wears mitre but teaches something else and by the way attacks alleged visionaries or apparition sites.

@English Catholic you are judging very severely and taking very risky stance over things you may in fact be wrong and one day accountable in front of God. I am saying this sincerely and with charity please be prudent and slow to judge any alleged apparition site because it is easy to make a mistake (especially in these times of great confusion) and you certainly don't want to be an obstacle against God's Will